What are advisory shares? How advisor equity works

Last updated

TL;DR

  • Advisory shares are ordinary equity (options or restricted stock) granted to advisors, not a special share class.
  • Grants are usually small fractions of a percent, sized by the company's stage and how much the advisor does.
  • Always vest the grant, and put it in a written advisor agreement.
  • Restricted stock can trigger a tax bill; an 83(b) election is time-sensitive.
  • Paying an advisor cash keeps your cap table clean and the commitment clear.

Advisory shares are equity, usually stock options or restricted stock, that a startup grants to advisors instead of cash. They aren't a separate class of stock. The grant is typically a small percentage of the company, vests over one to two years, and is set out in a written advisor agreement.

Advisory shares are how many startups pay advisors when cash is tight: a small grant of equity in exchange for advice, introductions and time. The name makes them sound like a special kind of stock. They aren’t. They’re ordinary equity, granted under a written agreement, usually with vesting.

What are advisory shares, exactly?

“Advisory shares” is shorthand for equity granted to an advisor. In practice it takes one of two forms:

  • Stock options, usually non-qualified stock options (NSOs), because incentive stock options are reserved for employees. The advisor gets the right to buy shares later at today’s price.
  • Restricted stock, actual shares the advisor owns from day one, subject to vesting. Common at the very earliest stage, when the share price is close to zero.

Either way, the grant comes out of the company’s equity, usually from the option pool, and it needs board approval like any other grant.

How much equity should an advisor get?

Usually a small fraction of a percent. Two things move the number:

  1. Stage. Equity is worth more the earlier it’s granted, so pre-seed companies tend to grant more than Series A companies for the same help.
  2. Engagement. An advisor who answers the occasional email earns less than one who meets monthly, makes introductions and works with your team.

Standard templates help you avoid negotiating from scratch. The Founder Institute’s FAST agreement (Founder/Advisor Standard Template) sets out ranges by stage and level of engagement, and many founders start there.

How should advisory shares vest?

Always vest the grant. Monthly vesting over one to two years is common, sometimes with a short cliff of around three months so that an advisor who disappears after the first meeting doesn’t keep anything. Include what happens if the company is acquired; many advisor agreements accelerate vesting on a change of control.

What goes in an advisor agreement?

At minimum: what the advisor will do, the equity and its vesting, confidentiality, assignment of any IP they create for you, and how either side can end it. Don’t skip the agreement because the grant is small. Cap table clean-up during due diligence is far more expensive than a template.

Taxes: the part people forget

If the advisor receives restricted stock, the value of the shares can be taxable income as they vest. An 83(b) election, filed with the IRS within 30 days of the grant, lets the advisor be taxed on the value at grant instead, which at the earliest stage may be close to nothing. Miss the 30 days and there’s no fix. Options are generally taxed when they’re exercised, not when they’re granted. Both founders and advisors should get their own tax advice.

Advisory shares vs paying an advisor cash

Equity aligns the advisor with the outcome and saves cash. It also adds a name to your cap table forever, for help that may last a year. Paying cash keeps the cap table clean and makes the commitment explicit: you know what you’re getting each month, and either side can stop.

A useful rule: grant equity for long-term, high-involvement help from someone whose name or network changes your odds, and pay cash for defined, recurring help. Many founders use both.

When not to grant advisory shares

  • The advisor hasn’t done anything yet. Start with a short trial period, then grant.
  • The help is a one-off. Pay for the hour or the project instead.
  • You can’t say what they’ll do. If the agreement’s “services” section is empty, the grant isn’t ready.

How Going Limitless advising works

Amanda Sanders advises founders and CEOs for a flat monthly fee, with no equity, so your cap table stays yours. Inner Circle clients get an advisory board seat, with Amanda’s name on the deck and the site, plus investor readiness and warm introductions chosen for the company’s stage. See how advising works.

Frequently asked questions

What are advisory shares?

Advisory shares are equity, usually stock options or restricted stock, that a startup grants to advisors instead of cash. They aren't a separate class of stock, and they normally vest over one to two years under a written advisor agreement.

How much equity should a startup advisor get?

Usually a small fraction of a percent. Earlier-stage companies and more involved advisors sit at the higher end; later-stage companies and lighter commitments at the lower end. Templates such as the Founder Institute's FAST agreement give ranges by stage and engagement.

Do advisory shares vest?

They should. Monthly vesting over one to two years is common, so an advisor who stops helping stops earning equity.

Are advisory shares taxable?

It depends on the form. Restricted stock can be taxable when it vests unless the advisor files an 83(b) election within 30 days of the grant; options are generally taxed on exercise. Advisors should get their own tax advice.